Continuing the Tradition
At Plus 1 Pizza our pizzas are made from our original family recipe created in 1977. Plus 1 Pizza is a local family owned and operated, by the same family today now with three generations to continue the family tradition. We take great pride in serving the highest quality products to our customers. Our pizzas are made with all-natural ingredients and do not contain any preservatives or artificial ingredients.
WeNEVER use any of the following in our pizzas: No partially hydrogenated oils, corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, cellulose, MSG, BHT, BHA.
We only use the highest quality, fresh, whole, natural ingredients go into every pizza we make!
Ingredients with integrity
Great ingredients are key to a great pizza. We make our dough from scratch each morning – chose from thin or regular fresh home made crust. Our sauce is made from the ripest tomatoes and mixed with our unique spice blend each morning. We have two awesome pizza sauces to choose from.
Our traditional family recipe pizza sauce, that is made 100% natural fresh with packed tomatoes, is a fresh made pizzas sauce that is lightly seasoned to allow the naturally sweet tomatoes to be the heart of this pizza sauce and is just slightly on the sweeter side. If you are looking for a pizza sauce that is more bold and spicy, we also have our bold Neapolitan sauce that has a much bolder flavor and more seasoning. The Neapolitan sauce leans to the spicy side and is not sweet. Both our homemade and Neapolitan is prepared fresh each day. Both are great sauces, depending on your preference of naturally sweeter sauce or bolder pizza sauce. The choice is yours!
On top, our premium mozzarella and provolone cheese is shredded fresh to maximize freshness and never produced with fillers or dry powder milk. Our cheese is 100 % natural-low moisture cheese that has a little firmer texture made with real milk and isn't watered down and mushy like you find at other pizza places
For toppings, our all-natural family recipe Italian sausage is prepared with a unique old-world family recipe. Unlike some competitors, our pepperoni and bacon are all natural, untouched by nitrates and fillers. To round out the flavor profile of our pizzas, we slice our fresh vegetables by hand each morning. You just cant make a great pizza without the freshest and more natural ingredients.
Whats goes into our pizza is what makes the difference
WE START WITH THE BEST INGREDIENTS
Do you know the real story behind what makes Plus 1 Pizza taste so unique? We are a small family operated pizzeria. Staying a small family owned pizzeria enables us to be independent and free to constantly find and source only the best ingredients possible. This enables us to create new recipes for our customers using only the freshest and all natural ingredients.
As a locally owned and family operated pizzeria, we are free to purchase only the best ingredients.
We're family owned and operated and able to do what is best for our customer, we choose only the freshest and highest quality ingredients.
We understand that if you’re going to build a masterpiece, you better start with all the best materials! Sauce made from fresh, vine-ripened tomatoes, authentic Italian sausage, select pepperoni made from a special family recipe, premium Italian cheeses, and fresh crispy veggies; we specially select and source each ingredient that goes into our pizzas. Simply put, our pizza is as great as the ingredients that go in it, fresh all natural ingredients go into every pizza.
FRESH DOUGH MADE DAILY
At Plus 1 Pizza, we don’t follow the crowd. We still make dough from scratch, fresh every morning in the back of our kitchens from the same homemade family recipe that has been handed down for over three generations. We use only the best spring wheat that money can buy. Sure, it costs more to make our dough this way, but it’s our way of giving you the freshest tasting, lightest texture, and most flavorful crust with every pizza we sell.
Dough lays the groundwork for our pizza. It’s where it all starts, so we make sure our dough is the best foundation for our homemade fresh made pizza.
Plus 1 Pizza’s sauce is prepared from rich natural tomatoes packed fresh within hours after being picked from the vine. Plus 1 Pizza’s sauce is freshly prepared every morning with a secret blend of spices passed down over 38 years ago from father to son, and finally to his grandchildren.
Family pride and quality tradition in the preparation of our pizza continues today and is our way to give our customers a pizza sauce prepared fresh daily from fresh packed natural tomatoes.
Great pizza starts with a great blend of premium Italian cheeses. Plus 1 Pizza uses only a premium blend of real Italian cheeses that is never frozen.
The result is a creamy, smooth, melt-in-your-mouth taste that gets your taste buds working. One taste of our premium Italian cheese and you will agree that fresh is always better then frozen and real is better than artificial. Our cheese is the best money can buy and with one taste we think you’ll agree.
We don’t skip on toppings by using a bunch of meat fillers and paper-thin pepperoni slices like so many others; we only use premium meat toppings having a robust flavor.
We only use fresh vegetables, cut daily by hand in our kitchens, the same way we’ve done it for over 38 years. By using only generous portions of quality meats and fresh vegetables is our way to bring you the best and freshest pizza in Athens. Find out more about our service and making our customers smile.
Topping Dictionary for over 45+ Epic Toppings
Mozzarella & Provolone
Next to our fresh made dough and family secret recipe sauce, our mozzarella/provolone cheese blend is what makes our pizza unique and full of flavor. We never use cheap diced and over processed cheese that all of our competitors use in town to lower the cost of their pizzas. We use only premium fresh shredded cheese. Absolutely the best cheese in town, don’t settle for anything else. This premium cheese goes onto every pizza we sell (only exception is our vegan pizza).
Add any of the other cheeses listed below as a topping to accent your pizza with different flavors.
Feta is a soft Greek cheese with a strong and rich flavor. Our crumbled feta melts perfectly into our mozzarella and provolone to provide a smoky taste. Try feta with spinach, chicken, pesto, or any veggie style pizza. Goes great with olives too.
Asiago is a hard Italian white cheddar style cheese. It complements pineapple, onions, and ham with a sweet aftertaste. When put on pepperoni, asiago browns and crisps for a “crunchy” effect.
This Italian Bleu cheese has bold flavor, strong aroma, and is delicious! Its wonderful taste goes well with hearty veggies. If you are going with a veggie style pizza add this cheese as a topping to kick up the flavor. Try it with roma tomatoes, sweet corn, or zucchini.
Shredded, mild cheddar is a wonderful compliment to virtually any pizza! No matter the other toppings, all toppings are better smothered in cheddar! Try it with bacon, broccoli, premium ground beef, or with roasted potatoes
A mild soft cheese which is a wonderful complement to virtually any pizza! This cheese is a little sweeter and great on any pizza. Try it with a plain cheese pizza with a pesto drizzle swirl.
A grated hard Italian cheese, Romano is one of the oldest Italian cheeses. Similar to parmesan cheese, it goes great on any pizza to add extra some zest and little salty flavor to any pizza.
Aged Sharp Cheddar
Sharp cheddar cheese sauce is way to add a lot of flavor to your pizza. Add to roasted potatoes, broccoli and zucchini.
Smoked Gouda Cheese
Smoked Gouda is sensational on any pizza, goes well with chicken, zucchini, roasted red peppers, and complements just about any veggie. This is a hard cheese from a Dutch cheese recipe named after the city of Gouda in the Netherlands. If truth be told, it is one of the most popular cheeses in the world and goes excellent on pizza.
For real cheese lovers! Our mozzarella/provolone blend is best cheese in town! Just ask for extra cheese and we’ll melt an extra helping on top of your pizza creation. It makes everything better!
Order a pizza with no cheese for a vegan pizza with veggie toppings.
We use premium pepperoni, Ohio sourced just an hour away. Never settle for highly processed national brands like Hormel and others. Our pepperoni is cut from premium meats and is dried cured with a unique family recipe that is full of flavor and “crisps” when cooked. We never use national chemically cured pepperoni like our competitors use to save money. Try it with our fresh sliced baby portabello mushrooms or our premium Italian sausage! You just can’t go wrong with our pepperoni on any pizza.
Old School Pepperoni
Our “old world pepperoni” is a smaller diameter which is old school and a throwback to how all pepperoni was done 30 years ago. It’s smaller in size and it’s spice profile is what sets it apart from the crowd. It’s a little more crispy for extra flavor and texture. Goes well with just about any other pizza topping on the menu. It's a classic!
As the name suggests, this random hand-sliced-style pepperoni is just a little spicy and adds just a little more kick to any pizza. Try all 3 styles of our premium pepperoni on our “Pepperoni Feast Pizza” it’s a true favorite of many of our customers. Beware it has a ton of pepperoni on this pizza. For the true pepperoni lovers.
Premium Italian sausage that is prepared from a secret family recipe. Made from the premium cuts a meat no fillers and oven roasted for the perfect flavor and texture.
Our bacon comes from premium cuts of meat. Try it and taste the difference! Goes well with pineapple, ham, chicken or broccoli.
Lean Ground Beef
100% lean ground beef makes for a savory pizza. Great for any pizza. Goes well with roasted garlic, cheddar cheese, bacon, pickles, onions, or green peppers.
Our lean, juicy ham goes great on any pizza. Try it with bacon, pineapple, or sausage and asiago cheese.
Premium seasoned white chicken is a lean meat that goes well with ranch sauce, bacon, onions, tomatoes, spinach, or with a BBQ or Buffalo drizzle.
Moist, thin-sliced steak will make any pizza a hearty meal. Try it with mushrooms, cheddar cheese sauce, roasted potatoes, or cheddar cheese.
Salami cured air-dried meat from lean beef and pork. Try salami with bacon, fresh mushrooms, or roasted red peppers.
A blend of beef, Italian spices and cheese, these HUGE meatballs are sliced to add serious taste to any pie. Try them with onions, green peppers, or cheddar.
Anchovies are for the few and very bold among us. Anchovies are filleted in salty oil and laid whole on our pizzas. They offer a different taste for meat lovers or a creative way to keep others from eating your pizza! Try anchovies with feta cheese, pepperoni, or onions.
Veggies & More
Our fresh mushrooms are baby portobello mushrooms. A meaty cultivated tan mushroom that is better quality and more expensive than other mushrooms other pizza places use, but worth it and are very tasty! Try them with green peppers, roasted red peppers, or sun-dried tomatoes.
Sweet, fire-roasted red peppers are awesome on a pizza. Substitute them for traditional green peppers and get a sweeter new taste sensation! Try them with spinach, roasted garlic, chicken, steak, or onions. Try adding a swirl of pesto drizzle.
Sweet corn kernels grown right here in Ohio. Corn is a perfect taste to many different pizzas. It's great on a veggie pizza. They add a nice “crunch” to any pizza. Try it with zucchini, broccoli, spinach, or roma tomatoes.
Whole leaves of tender baby spinach. Fresh spinach adds a light, subtle taste to any pizza and goes very well with chicken and about any vegetable. Try it with feta cheese, black olives, or roasted red peppers.
Sliced fresh each day, zucchini is a green squash. Zucchini goes great with sweet corn, gorgonzola cheese, roasted red peppers, and chicken.
Fresh broccoli florets are hand-cut each morning for every pizza. Broccoli is high in fiber and you’ll love broccoli with cheddar, black olives, or roma tomatoes.
Round crispy seasoned tater tots take pizza to a whole new level. Try them with green onions, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, or bacon.
These Italian tomatoes are sun dried and full of flavor! Sun-dried tomatoes have a richer, robust flavor than regular tomatoes and go wonderfully with spinach, feta cheese, green olives, or black olives.
Sliced artichoke hearts are a great meat substitute for veggie lovers! A hearty “meaty” taste that is complemented with roasted red peppers, black olives, asiago cheese, or roasted garlic.
Large slices of golden potatoes take pizza to a whole new level of taste and texture. Try them with broccoli, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, or bacon.
We hand slice delicious onions each day for our pizzas. Never dehydrated, never frozen. Try them with any other topping, you just can’t go wrong.
We hand slice delicious red onions each day always fresh. Try them with any other topping.
We purchase large, whole green peppers and hand chop them fresh each morning for each pizza. Fresh cut daily just tastes better. Sometimes referred to as bell peppers. Try them with onions, fresh mushrooms, or Italian sausage.
Yellow, crunchy peppers add a little zest to uninspired pizzas without lighting up your mouth. Sometimes called ”Hot Peppers” but they’re actually mild. Try them with zucchini or other vegetables, pepperoni, bacon, olives, or ham.
Green onions are young shoots of bulb onions, they are milder tasting than large bulb onions. They have a small bulb, with long green stalks and a mild pleasant flavor. Goes will with sliced potato, tater tots, roma tomatoes, red peppers, and chicken.
These are some extra hot peppers! Fresh sliced jalapenos add a spicy kick and crunch to any pizza! Goes great on any pizza that you want to add some heat. Try with a buffalo drizzle and chicken.
California green olives boast a sharp taste. Olives add a boost to any veggie pizza and go with many toppings.
They are a fully ripe olive. A firm black olive is a mild flavor that goes well with roasted red peppers, onions, or pepperoni.
Fresh hand sliced every day. We never get produce pre-diced or dehydrated, so each tomato is hand sliced daily to bring you the freshest taste. Try them with black olives, Italian sausage, chicken, or spinach.
Sweet, juicy pineapple makes the perfect Hawaiian Pizza! Try them with ham and bacon. Pineapple is good on a lot of different pizzas and adds just a little sweetness to your pizza
Chopped fresh garlic cloves. Once roasted, garlic mellows out in flavor. Amazing with any veggie to add some extra flavor or try it with Italian sausage or jalapenos.
A wonderful fresh herb with a wide delicate lacy green leaf and a strong pleasant flavor. Goes well with roma tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, zucchini, corn, red peppers, and chicken. Used in most in salsas and Latin dishes and goes well with pizza.
Fresh basil is a versatile herb that adds bright flavor to almost any pizza. Goes best with roma tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, ricotta cheese, red peppers, and chicken
Pickles go well with our ground beef, onions, cheddar cheese, or sausage.
Crushed Red Peppers
Hot and spicy and will add a lot of heat to your pizza. Dried and crushed peppers that includes jalapeno, cayenne peppers, and the seeds to increase the spice level.
A unique basil pesto sauce that is swirled right onto the pizza as a topping. Try it with artichoke hearts or feta cheese. Vegans: Pesto does contain Parmesan Cheese! Pesto-Basil sauce with fresh basil, olive oil, garlic, parmesan cheese, and pine nuts
These is honey BBQ sauce that is swirled on top to add a unique flavor to any pizza. It stands out on the Voodoo Pizza.
Customers love our ranch sauce and can’t get enough. As a drizzle it goes on top the and is swirled in with the toppings for added flavor.
Garlic Butter & Herb Drizzle
A mixture of garlic butter and herbs and spices. It adds flavor to any pizza.
Our own hot buffalo sauce to add just the right kick to any pizza.
Family Recipe Pizza Sauce
Our original family recipe. Our signature naturally sweet red tomato sauce that's made fresh daily in a Plus 1 Pizza tradition.
Bold Neapolitan Red Sauce
Red tomato sauce packed with more garlic and oregano for customers that like a little more garlic and with a touch of olive oil.
A savory combination of our signature red sauce and buttery garlic sauce.
Fresh Garlic Sauce
Minced-from-the-clove garlic with extra virgin olive oil for just the right flavor. Made for true garlic lovers.
Pesto-Basil sauce, made with extra virgin olive oil, parmesan cheese, fresh basil, pine nuts, and other herbs for just the right flavors.
Garlic Butter Herb Sauce
Butter garlic sauce with blend of Italian seasoning and herbs.
Honey BBQ sauce that is savory and just a little tangy and sweet.
Garlic Herb – Crust Topper
Go for it, add some extra flavor to your crust, try a crust topper. Garlic butter, parmesan cheese, and Italian seasonings.
Ranch Flavor Crust Topper
Ranch seasoning for your pizza crust, for ranch lovers everywhere!
Blend of butter and Romano cheese
Creamy ranch sauce
Original Classic Crust
An original, classic medium-thick crust, light and airy with a home-baked flavor.
Crispy Thin Crust
Crispy thin crust that bakes to a golden brown with an extra crispy texture. Our thin crust lets the full flavor from the cheese and toppings hit your taste buds.
Coming Soon – Deep Dish
Thicker crust with a pleasing crunch on the outside, soft and tender on the inside.
Gluten Free Crust
Gluten Free** Medium size only
**gluten free items are prepared in a common kitchen with the risk of gluten exposure. Therefore, We DO NOT recommend this pizza for customers with celiac disease. Gluten free crust is not made in house and is a prepared product