Pintrest Code Youtube Verify Google Ad Remarketing Tag

About Us

Find out what we are all about

Our History and what we do

We’re a small family owned and operated pizzeria.  We are three generations of pizza restaurateurs. Plus 1 Pizza was founded in 1977, by Bob Fettes Sr. with his passion and goal to make a fresh, local pizza that would be the best is his hometown. As the demand grew for a fresh, local pizza in neighboring communities his son, Bob Jr, continued the craft of making fresh homemade pizzas and grew this idea to other communities. In 2014, Bob Jr son, Cole, entered in the family business and his father’s passion for making fresh, handcrafted pizzas.  

Our idea is simple – make the freshest and best pizza possible by sourcing only the freshest and highest quality ingredients. We work hard each day to provide great service and make people smile, each guest every day. We have fun. We love what we do. And we want anyone to know what we are about. 

We make fresh, handcrafted pizza that people connect over. That’s our thing. We know we’re not negotiating world peace treaties, but we take our job seriously. We live by a set of core values each and every day. We want you to know that when you order from us you can count on us to take your pizza order seriously, that’s what we do.  

We also have a “huge dislike” for what the big pizza corporations do to pizza and their the lack of respect for the very thing we love–a fresh, local pizza. Grandma would always say we shouldn't use the word–hate–when speaking about those other pizza places but you get the idea.

Our Mission Statement: To delight every customer one pizza at a time and to be the best pizzeria in the world by killing it on every detail of the customer experience.

Our Core Values 
– Have fun 
– Do it with passion
– Build something special
– Give back to the community
– Give Customers what they want
– Source only the highest quality and freshest ingredients

We have a team of hardworking dedicated team members that share our passion for preparing great pizza and making customers smile.

Respect great pizza! Join us in our passion.  Enjoy life, have fun, and eat better pizza.  

Cole Fettes, Bob Jr,  & Bob Sr
Bob Sr., Retired

Enjoy Life, Have Fun... Eat Better Pizza


Athens 740-594-9494       Cambridge 740-439-1333      Byesville  740-685-1999      Coshocton  740-622-9300    Caldwell  740-732-551

Word Up......What People Say About Us

"This pizza has been perfect everytime, so absolutely delicious I would suggest the bold neopolitan pizza sauce on a thin crust with spicy pepperoni! So good!! Thank you Athens plus one pizza!" - Earl Wood

Earl Wood
Athens Ohio

“ I love their pizza..... I think they quite possibly have the best pizza I have ever had. Their sauce is a little sweeter which I love, and the crust is delicious as well.  Everything is always perfect when I order. Give them a shot, they might just become your new favorite.

Katie B. 
Athens Ohio

“This place is great. I left Athens for a while and moved back and was surprised to see it there. I decided to order from them to give them a try, and now I get them more than any other Athens pizza, they are affordable (unlike a certain place down the street), their staff is amazing, and I have never had a problem with my order (again...unlike that certain place down the street). There are plenty of pizza places in Athens, but most of them are either chains that you can find anywhere or that one place that sells novelty pizzas that cost an arm and a leg and seem more like absurd experiments than food. Also, if you sign up with Plus 1, you get all kinds of deals, they routinely e-mail me great deals. I don't really ever write reviews, but I like this place so much that I feel the least I can do is ...”

David Nabel
Athens Ohio

“Staff goes out of their way to help you out and make sure you are satisfied. New favorite pizza joint in Athens!”

Zach Schabel
Athens Ohio

 Pizza and wings were awesome. Staff were all friendly when I picked up my order. Glad you guys came to Athens.

Fran Cline
Athens Ohio

“Pizza sub was awesome! There was enough sauce, cheese, and meats to make the perfect sub. it wasn't too crispy, wasn't too dry, and it wasn't bare! Fantastic flavor, and an amazing job!”

Zach Sinclair
Athens Ohio

 We have done  pickup orders.....done when we get there and still hot, tastes great and exactly what we ordered. Please keep up the good work.

Amber Miller
Athens Ohio

I've had Plus 1 three times since they opened (twice delivery, once dine in). Everyone is super friendly and the food is delicious! The delivery times are also crazy reasonable (if you're ordering during the lunch and dinner rushes, don't expect to get it in 30 minutes, just saying). Each delivery I got was made in 30-45 minutes, and I love their online gps tracker. Keep supporting these awesome folks. They may be a little green, but they're soon to be a local favorite!

 Katey Burgess
Athens Ohio

Friendly people and GREAT food. Best Pizza Sauce in Athens Hands Down!  You guys do a great job. You're making the other pizza places look really bad...

David White
Athens Ohio